As I was doing some research on historic places in Bellmore, NY I came to one that is still standing today. The Bedell Family Farm House located on South St. Mark’s Avenue is a nice step back in time. It is the oldest house in Bellmore and has been here since 1689. That’s a good 323 years ago! Just try to imagine how this area was back then. Life was much simpler back in those days. It makes me wish that today was more like yesterday.
The Bedells were among some of the first settlers of the area. Robert Bedell came to New York from England with his wife Blanche in the 1600s. They were married in 1643 and gave birth to their son John in 1648. Years later after Blanche had passed, he married Sarah Southard. They both lived in this home and had a family of four sons and three daughters. Sarah passed away at age fifty four on Feb. 26, 1716 and John died two months later the same year at the age of 68.
Born in 1662, Sarah was the oldest daughter of Thomas Southard and Annica Jansen. She had four brothers and sisters. The Southards were a big family in the area and they were a big part of the economic changes in Bellmore. The Southard genes go way back when they held the name Southworth in England.
A 1906 map it shows that David Bedell was the owner of the land. By this time the railroad was built and the area still consisted of farms, housing, and a few hotels and stores. A 1914 map it has John J. Bedell’s name listed for that land. Later in 1927, there was much change to Bellmore and the surrounding areas. There were more highways and occupied land as well as commercial property.
The Bedell family members are said to have lived in the historic house until 1950, making additions to the building in 1778 and 1872. However, it still contains the original fireplace as well as the barn, which was rebuilt in 1810, and the carriage house, which was constructed 10 years later. When I made my visit to the historic site I must say that the building needs some love. I admired the federal style architecture and its unique characteristics. This type of design focused on balance and symmetry and was inspired by ancient Greece and Rome.
I am sure if you live in Bellmore you have passed the Bedell House many times and may have even known families that have lived there. Just think of the history behind the building, the land it stands on and the memories that it holds. So many families have shared moments and days with this area of Bellmore and its important to never forget that. Holding on to the past may never push you forward, but remembering our history and keeping it alive will allow big leaps into the future with a new view.





Pass this house everyday
You will likely never see this, as this is an old post, but-the Bedell Farmhouse was originally located on Merrick Road, where the Hess gas station is on the corner of South St. Mark’s and Merrick Road. In about 1970 or so, it was lifted and moved around the corner to its current spot. It was quite a sight, I remember it clearly-they used these big rollers to move it and big trucks. Everyone in the neighborhood came out and watched. It may have been when they were widening Merrick Road, not sure. But nothing I read about the Bedell House ever seems to mention that it is not in its original location! Enjoying your blog about my old neighborhood!
That is pretty important and not sure why no one ever mentions it. Very strange. But thanks for reading and sharing that informative fact!
My grandmother owned this house..spent my childhood there
I am looking for any information on old houses in Bellmore as we owned one for 30 years. 1976-2006 The oldest house left standing on the Bellmore Penninsula.
I know that it was considered a Daughter house’ One of three houses built for ‘his’ three daughters. We bought it from Mansfield in 1976/ I thought the Mansfields were the original owners and we were the second owners.
I am looking for info on if one of Bedells daughters married a Mansfield.
We had the old inn opposite us on Newbridge Rd and hewlett lasne, The mounting block for horses was still there when we left in 2006
Anywhere that can help lead me to info historical would help’
Thanks J. Mills.
PS: I have not seen anything on the Inn either at the fork of Newbridge Rd and Hewlett lane
You don’t have all the correct information..the house was originally resided on merrick rd till my grandmother had it moved to the west side of the property